If you score a big slab of hussar on a 9/0 as 10 out of 10 then this would be my score for the other methods;
Bait....10
Gulp or other large scented sp....8
Big blades................................... 7
Octa, lucanis, etc.........................4
Knifes..........................................1
I have been anchored on a big school of reds, with say 4 or 5 hooked up at any time, cut off my bait, tied on a jig, dropped it down...and caught a little trevally, then a hussar, then nothing, then gave up, while it continued to rain reds around me. Have tried a few different sizes and styles without success. Maybe I'm just hopeless?
It might change in very deep water, we fish between 40m and 60m.... normally about 42m. Might be a bit better in say 120m??