GTPopping.com - Giant Trevally, GTPopping, Topwater & GT Fly-Fishing Resource

Topwater Caranx Ignobilis: Giant Trevally (GT) => Tackle & Techniques => Topic started by: Ludovic Goldschmidt on June 05, 2011, 07:20:28 PM

Title: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Ludovic Goldschmidt on June 05, 2011, 07:20:28 PM
hello,need your advices about stickbait rods.want a rod for lures between 140and 180g whithout hooks. fish whith varivas avani gt in 100 lbs and drag max about 12 kg.the best stickbait is for me the carpenter gamma 160 grs,need a rod for this lure and orion big foot and big nambas 170 grs too.
thanks for your advices.
ludo
   
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Andy Rowe on June 05, 2011, 07:37:56 PM
MH80H  :D
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Ben Furness on June 05, 2011, 08:24:20 PM
MH80H  :D

Seems to be a popular choice for poppers/stickbaits under 200g. Does it suit both styles of fishing?
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Brandon Khoo on June 05, 2011, 08:45:47 PM
For Gamma 160, my preference would be a Carpenter TBL711 or Ripple Ultimo 79MH or 83MH. For the Orions, most rods would do the job.
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Andy Rowe on June 05, 2011, 09:41:25 PM
MH80H  :D

Seems to be a popular choice for poppers/stickbaits under 200g. Does it suit both styles of fishing?

(/quote]

Ben, it will do both. Not ideal for big faced chugging lures over 150gm though I have used 150gm skipjacks and GT2 and it is fine for them. Due to the 250gm lure max stated on the rod I am thinking it was designed more to handle the big 200gm gammas. It is not a finesse rod but if you could take only 1 GT rod into potentially big GT country to cast medium poppers and big stickbaits a long way it would be great.

Andy





Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Ludovic Goldschmidt on July 10, 2011, 04:40:24 PM
perhaps coral viper is the best rod for gamma 160 or big foot 180?
OR RIPPLE ULTIMO 79 H?

YOUR ADVICE
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Luke Seyrek on July 10, 2011, 06:28:53 PM
For Gamma 160, my preference would be a Carpenter TBL711 or Ripple Ultimo 79MH or 83MH. For the Orions, most rods would do the job.

Hi Brandon, would you say there's much difference between the Ultimo 83MH and Ripple Long cast 82 as the specs seem very similar.
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Brandon Khoo on July 10, 2011, 06:49:27 PM
Luke, the Ultimo 83MH has a softer tip than the 82LC but you're right - they are similar
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Luke Seyrek on July 10, 2011, 08:55:00 PM
Thanks for confirming that Brandon. Have a friend tossing up between the 2 rods will pass it on, cheers!
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Andy Rowe on July 10, 2011, 09:04:05 PM
Personally i would say the 160 gamma would be the heaviest unrigged lure for the CV, for me it feels and casts better with lures (rigged) to around 150-160gm maximum. I'd be going for a bigger rod with 180gm unrigged lures.

perhaps coral viper is the best rod for gamma 160 or big foot 180?
OR RIPPLE ULTIMO 79 H?

YOUR ADVICE
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Antonino Augugliaro on July 30, 2011, 05:04:34 PM
Some news about EP 82/38? Should be good choice for stick in 160 gr range? Has someone check This rod jet? I'm thinking to some rods, but choice isn't easy: rp ultimo 83mh or 79h, carpenter cv 79/40, tbl 711/35, ep 82/38, yamaga blue reef  710/8 710/10. Some of these are pe 10 rods and my fear is that should be to stiff for floating stick bait. My be better a pe8 for This range of stick ( 140-180 gr)? Sorry for the enquire, but I need to make order before purchase.
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Brandon Khoo on July 30, 2011, 05:34:17 PM
All the rods you have mentioned will do the job.
Of course a lighter tip will be better for a 160 Gamma but if you want to use PE10, then not much choice. If you want to use PE8, then obviously, a PE8 rod would be more suitable for the lure.
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Antonino Augugliaro on July 30, 2011, 07:11:08 PM
Thanks Brandon,
I've some little trubles whit english, so I can't explain well, but I've appreciate your answer.
For stick in this range I'll fish whit PE7-8, so now I can exclude some models on PE10 rating.
For bigger stick (gamma 200, 250) I think to go on a Monster Hunter 79EH or other rods in similar class (whit this rod I intend to pop G-I cup too).

So my set up will be as follow:

1) stick bait up to 160 (unrigged): EP82/38, CV79/40, TBL 711/35.
2) stick bait up to 250: MH79EH, Tokara60, RF FS79H.

My be CV79/40 should replace also my GTGame for medium popping, up to 150gr?
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Brandon Khoo on July 30, 2011, 08:26:17 PM
It depends on which GT Game you have - T-RS or T-RSH. T-RSH is definitely stronger than CV79.
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Antonino Augugliaro on July 30, 2011, 09:17:35 PM
I've Tr-s model, Brandon
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Brandon Khoo on July 30, 2011, 09:27:33 PM
If it is a T-RS, the CV will definitely cast better
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Antonino Augugliaro on July 31, 2011, 12:08:40 AM
Thanks Brandon  :)
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Jon Li on July 31, 2011, 12:44:50 AM
Stickbaiting for GT was pioneered by Konishi-san of Carpenter , so why not choose Carpenter rods for the task ?

Jon .
Title: Re: best stickbait rod for carpenter gamma 160 grs and orion big foot 180g
Post by: Antonino Augugliaro on July 31, 2011, 03:50:04 AM
Stickbaiting for GT was pioneered by Konishi-san of Carpenter , so why not choose Carpenter rods for the task ?

Jon .

Hi Jhon,
I had chance to try some carpenter model and really like these. Main problem is for rods never seen before, never check personally. This is the reason of my questions.  But for my stick bait rod I'll go for Carpenter. Not for blason of company, but for quality of products.