GTPopping.com - Giant Trevally, GTPopping, Topwater & GT Fly-Fishing Resource
Topwater Caranx Ignobilis: Giant Trevally (GT) => Tackle & Techniques => Topic started by: Kenny Tan on February 02, 2015, 08:35:23 PM
-
Popping gurus,
Anyone used a 20000PG reel for popping?
Pros and cons
-
Hi Kenny,
Assuming you are talking about an SW Stella; I can tell you that it is totally fine to do so, should your budget be limiting you to a single reel. I did it when i first started because I began jigging, rather than popping, and didn't have the money for both initially. The drawback is that due to the slower retrieval rate you will find, especially when using surface stickbaits, that recovering the line after a sweep will require a fair bit more winding. It will certainly be more of a workout! When you can afford it, get the 18K for popping; you will notice a big difference after a day of casting! There is a slight weight difference too which is negligible really and casting off the 20K spool may be very marginally different in casting distance in comparison because it is wider in diameter.
That is my humble opinion if your budget is tight. Coming from my limited experience compared to many other members of this great forum.
Take care.
-
No problems at all when you're using a popper.
It's a little more difficult to work a stickbait with but doable.
Trev
-
Thanks guys. ;)
-
I pop and stickbait using an 08 20K. Mind you, this is off the bricks chasing kings, where im only fishing for a couple of hours at a time.
If you have used HG reels alot in the past then it may feel a bit sluggish and hard to keep up, but once you get a rythm going working a stickbait with a PG reel, you eventually don't really think much about it. Just a faster tempo.
This is my experience anyway, I'm sure there are alot better people on here able to offer advice on the subject
-
I am one of the rare few who prefers a slower speed reel. Even for popping. Difference tho is that I am right handed but use the right hand to crank as well. I just crank faster. :)
In fact - I used the new 5500h but could not quite get used to the speed. At least for a few hours. Got the hang of it only after then.
Prefer a slow speed reel!
-
I find it much easier to adjust to a slower speed reel than a high speed reel. Sometimes it is hard to reel slow(with a high speed reel) and get the right cadence, especially for jigging. If I were stuck with 1 reel it would be a slower speed reel. I can always reel faster.
Case in point, I have a Van Staal 275 which is very slow gearing. It makes it on every trip with me and gets used quite a bit for jigging, popping and stickbaits. My Saltigas with 5.7:1 gears stay on my casting setups. Except the 3500/4000 which have small enough spools to be used for jigging even with the high gear ratio.
-
Amr summed it up perfectly for you ;)
right on the money!
Tight lines
Sami
-
Hi Zeck,
Long time no see or hear from you. ;D
Same as u, I'm one of the few who crank using right hand...hahahaha
Preparing for a big trip and has 2 x 08 Stella SW20000PG in hand now. So looking to get another 1 or 2 new Stella and thus contemplating on whether to get a HG or PG. ;D
Thanks guys for sharing your experiences.