Sacco,
I wouldn't want your death on my conscience.
For the last few years I've fished with rods that are all rounders that handle both stick baits and poppers and that's worked fine but there is always a compromise. Large poppers are always problematic for the 'all rounder' class of rod. They handle smaller and medium poppers fine but when you want to bring the big boys out nothing beats a rod that's designed for it.
My two 'all rounders' are:
1. Carpenter Monster Hunter 80H
2. Carpenter Endless Passion 85/36
I've been looking to add a rod for big poppers like the Hammerhead G cup and I think I may have recently found what I'm after.
My 'all rounders' are mainly used for stickbaits in any case, although the MH 80H handles medium poppers fine and even, for short spells, the big boys. However, it's just not optimal.
The choices are personal. I'm sure others will have a totally different approach depending on where they fish and the fish they target.
Regards,
Trev