GTPopping.com - Giant Trevally, GTPopping, Topwater & GT Fly-Fishing Resource
Topwater Caranx Ignobilis: Giant Trevally (GT) => Tackle & Techniques => Topic started by: Jussi Saarinen on April 05, 2014, 05:40:57 AM
-
I am looking for a second heavy (up to PE12) GT rod that is more forgiving (parabolic/new/nano tech) than my old 2006/07 Carpenter Wild Violence 80XH. I would like a rod that is between 7.5 and 8 feet in length and can throw and work heavy (250g) large cup poppers effectively.
The rods I have identified/looked at so far are:
1. Ripple Fisher Final Spirit GT78XH
2. Hots Gipang 77XXXH
3. Carpenter Monster Hunter MH79XH
4. A newer Carpenter Wild Violence 80XH
5. Hammerhead Faube 77H
6. PATRIOT DESIGN World Combat GTZ Black Mafia 76
I would highly appreciate any views on these rods and any recommendations re other alternatives.
/Jussi
-
Jussi, I think you will struggle to find a rod capable of working poppers to 250 grams that is as forgiving as the WV80XH you already have.
Something like a Ripple Fisher Final Spirit 78XH for example is a very brutal and stiff rod but would be a suitable choice for poppers of that size.
Numbers 2 and 3 on your list will not handle a chugger anything like as big as 250 grams.
I wonder why you are looking to use poppers that big? There are hardly any of that size available anyway?
-
Mark, sorry, I should have written "up to" 250 g. I am looking for a rod that can handle big chuggers in the 200-250 g range, fully rigged. I am curious if there are any rods that can handle these lures that are a bit more parabolic/forgiving on the angler than my old WV80XH without sacrificing too much in casting distance (hence 7.5'' plus). I already have a RP300, which does the job but at 7.2'' in length, it does it at a price. Fully aware that shorter rods will mean shorter casts but would be interested in hearing views also on casting distance, when comparing rods of equal/similar (+/- 1'') length.
/Jussi
-
For 200-250 you can still rule out options 2 and 3 on your list.
Option 1. Will handle it.
I would imagine the Faube and the Black Devil also would but they are not rods I have seen much of.
An 8 foot rod which would handle chuggers this size is the Ripple Fisher Infinity 80. But that is out of production. I have one and it is a beast but a bit more manageable than a Final Spirit GT78XH.
-
Jussi,
A forgiving rod is rubbish for working big poppers period! Either man up and buy a broomstick or fish large stick baits, pencils and small poppers with a rod you can manage. You can still raise big fish with large profile stick baits and pencil poppers.
Chris
-
Chris, "man up" - I love it! LOL
As stated, I have a WV80XH that I use to throw the big boys. However, given that is close to ten years since I bought the rod, I was just wondering if there is a rod that can get the job done but is somewhat more forgiving on the angler. A rod that utilizes the development in nano technology and new blank materials during the last five to ten years. I would be surprised if the answer to that question is no.
/Jussi
-
Jussi
Carpenter UPL 75/45 but one must wait for this regular rod version of KLL 75/45 , may be later this year or early next year .
Jon .
-
Like Chris, I suspect the answer to your question is actually no Jussi. If you think about it, a rod that works 200-250 gram poppers has to be stiff by its very nature.
Now you might find rods lighter in weight than an old style WV or SP, but I do not see how they can be less stiff and still work a massive chugger efficiently.
You could just wimp out like me most of the time and not use any poppers bigger than 190 grams :) . You can then get away with a modern, parabolic XH type rod like Monster Hunter 79 XH. Having recently seen the Temple Reef Reefer 76-12 in action a lot, that one would fit into this category also.
-
Thx Jon. Seems like there are some interesting heavy rods in the making - Temple Reef Big Bertie, Carpenter UPL 75/45, rewamp of Ripple Fisher etc.
Mark, I refuse to wimp out, although that is probably where I will end up eventually :). In the mean time, I am planning to get fit (again) to be able to tackle these brutes. My second largest S. Oman GT, the 51 kg that I hooked minutes after having landed another 30kg+, that was foul hooked and had me crying like a baby some 5-10 min into the fight and eventually forced me to hand over the rod for the first time in my life, really got me motivated >:(
-
Hi Jussi,
Good to hear your having go! The ripple xh and the pd black mafia are both excellent large popper rods. Both take a lot of effort to use and cast. The mafia is a bit nicer to fight fish with being a little shorter and the tip of the rod has a little give. I have this rod myself and use gt3 ultra cups, pd masterd bomb big cup 220 and stickbaits over 250g no rigging.
Chris
-
The best of luck to you Jussi.
Fishing for truly large GTs like the 51 kg fish you mention using a stiff large popper rod is whole new degree of physicality from that you experienced when handing the rod over. The strength and fitness program will need to be pretty extreme :)
-
I let this thread run for a bit waiting to see if someone might suggest a BLC. After all, I've found out in the past few days that it is a GT killing machine and that it can handle 150g poppers! ;D
The concept of a forgiving rod for really big poppers is a pipe dream. Whatever forgiveness there is in the rod will translate into saturation of the blank when you are popping - plain and simple.
A WV80 is not suitable for giant poppers - it saturates too much.
-
LOL @ the ongoing BLC stuff :) .
-
Patriot Design Zanzibar 82. Very fun rod!
8'2" fits your casting length desires + all the hurt you can put and take!!!
-
How about the carpenter SP78EXH will this fit to his list as No.7 ??
as I haven't tried the 200-250g range popper on the EXH rod yet ..
as I am keen to try the 190g Craftbait popper on it
I know that the UHL is a Broomstick so thought maybe EXH will do the job ?
-
EXH is strong. UHL is stronger!!
-
I let this thread run for a bit waiting to see if someone might suggest a BLC. After all, I've found out in the past few days that it is a GT killing machine and that it can handle 150g poppers! ;D
The concept of a forgiving rod for really big poppers is a pipe dream. Whatever forgiveness there is in the rod will translate into saturation of the blank when you are popping - plain and simple.
A WV80 is not suitable for giant poppers - it saturates too much.
I saw someone mention this not long ago and chuckled ;D
-
More of a progressive action, check out the Fisherman TRSH GT Game 76...an all-time favourite that will handle an I-Cup class lure with ease (albeit a lot of sweat!)
-
You selling that flash EXH you have are u Mick? Not many of the super popping series for sale these days.